| Name | Dates | Name | Dates |
| Alexander Shorts | 1883-1896 | Douglas Cook | Summers 1955-1958 |
| Roscoe C. Smith | April 1899-April 1901 | Peter Sabey | June 1959- September 1959 |
| John Calkins | May 1901-April 1904 | Garry Camolli | June 1960-September 1960 |
| W. J. Shaw | April 1904-October 1905 | Edward Youngs | June 1961-September 1961 |
| T. J. C. Warren | November 1905-May 1907 | John Marks | Summers 1962-1963 |
| Francis E. Loan | May 1907-May 1908 | Robert V. Smith | Summers 1964-1973 |
| S. Fergusons | May 1908-April 1909 | Hoyt P. Oliver | Summer 1974 |
| L. H. Robinswon | April 1909-May 1914 | Robert H. Matheson | Summer 1975 |
| W. S. T. Walshe | June 1914-December 1914 | Bruce Clark | Summer 1976 |
| William Arthur Whiston | January 1915-September 1919 | Richard Sivers | Summer 1977 |
| Daniel A. Wright | October 1919-Febuary 1923 | Stanley D. Walters | Summers 1978-1979 |
| Ross P. Dieter | May 1923-July 1923 | A. H. Mathias Zahniser | Summers 1980-1982 |
| Hollis M. French | October 1923-April 1924 | Dora J. Schneider | Summer 1983 |
| Mrs. Florence A. Printer | June 1925-July 1930 | Island Consortium See Note 1 | Summer 1984 |
| Mrs. L. Rose Wright | June 1931-May 1933 | Elaine Cleeton | Summers 1985-1987 |
| Warren W. VanBuren | June 1933-September 1935 | Mary Beth Taylor | Summer 1988 |
| Basil R. Gabriel | June 1935-May 1945 | Robert V. Smith | Summers 1989-1990 |
| Donald H. Bishop | June 1945-October 1945 | William C. Gipson | Summer 1991 |
| David Sparling | June 1946-September 1946 | NCNY Confer. - See Note 2 | Summer 1992 |
| W. A. Gardner | June 1947-October 1951 | Barbara Kuempel | Summer 1993 |
| Burton A. MacLean | June 1952-June 1953 | Mary Beers | Summers 1994-1997 |
| Kehrer | 1954-1954 | Jane E. Wagner | Summer 1998 |
| Richard Petry | Summer 1999 |
| Note #1: The Island Consortium consisted of: John Marks, Robert V. Smith, Andrew Davidson and Craig Heverly. |
Note #2: The NCNY Conference consisted of: Burton Sweet, David Geer, Robert V. Smith, Garrie Stevens and Wislon Kilgore. |
| Note #3: This list was provided by Jane E. Wagner, Summer 1998. |